What label are you trying to duplicate? the best and most intricate labels I see around here are for the Wacky Tabacky groups - they seem to use vinyl and a textured laminae... not really thin. printing to a cheap 2mil vinyl will give a thinner feel... Some labels are printed on a paper substrate, not vinyl. You should be able to source some, not sure about small quantities in rolls - sheet fed you can purchase letter size boxes of 100 sheets. Many different types of paper media for labels....