Need feedback

[reQ]

Here is short story. 3 years ago i had a guy who was working for me for 3 month make me a logo. I did not worry about it to much so i was okay with whatever he did. But right now i don't like it at all, in my opinion is terrible & not good looking lol. So i spent some time and did new one myself.
I wanted to keep planet + circle around it but wanted to make it more clean.

Bottom one is old one, top ones are new

P.S. The one on the right was just an experiment, since i accidently deleted half of the plant lol.

Any feed back would be much appreciated.

Thank you

 

[J Hill Designs]

on the top left one, center the planet, not the planet + ring -- it looks off centered as it sits right now

 

[reQ]

on the top left one, center the planet, not the planet + ring -- it looks off centered as it sits right now

 

[BigfishDM]

Looks good!