This certainly deserves some more research and looking in to the various tapes.
Again, I would not do it, but that could very easily be old school. I had a few of 3M's stronger than f*ck tape examples in our shop. The most aggressive one being aluminum to aluminum tape...... just for this application. After a coupla years, we were able to pull the two apart. It was still strong, but nothing I would ever consider using in place of physical fasteners. I still remember the two 3M representatives coming into the shop with these samples and telling me there was no way we could ever pull them apart. When I called back to tell them it failed, both guys were gone.
I still believe in VHB for many many situations, but a sign cabinet with expansion and contraction, internal heat, exterior elements, wind force, freezing elements getting in every nook & cranny...... I'll give it a try for the gipper and see what we come up with.
To be continued.