OK....After much work....

[J Hill Designs]

OK - this is rough, but it's the idea I was talking about. That is our pumpkin shaped water tower

Hand drew it then threw it into illy and traced it out.

Thoughts on the idea, if not the execution?

honestly looking at it, i read 'and' as 'pue'

 

[Marlene]

the concept of the water tower isn't all that bad as that sure is a landmark. re-work it so it is less detailed

 

[Colin]

the concept of the water tower isn't all that bad as that sure is a landmark. re-work it so it is less detailed

Unless it's already been done to death in your area.

 

[MatthewTimothy]

i dont think you have identified truley what you want. You can all the ideas in the world but until you can define on how you want to represent your logo, then you will be making logo ideas for ever.

A great logo will be able to display in any color, and this includes starting off with just 1 color designs. After you get the 1 color design done and are happy then start adding colors.

 

[Circleville Signs]

Water tower idea hasn't been done in our area at all...

 

[Gino]

I could see using that water tower if it was for the municipality, you made them or some other connected reason, but other than to locals.... you've now sponsored 50% of your logo with a non-meaningful geometrical shape. Your name has now taken a back-seat to a pumpkin.

I think you can do better. Like I said earlier, unless you're on some kinda time schedule, let this go for a while. It'll come..................... eventually. :Sleeping:

 

[Letterbox Mike]

Shwing






.

Yes.

 

[2B]

Tweak!



.

Very clean lines! this one speaks volumes. Never been a fan of est. if you want to claim when you started, try QUALITY SINCE '08 or something to that effect

 

[Jillbeans]

Don't tilt the "and" an ampersand would look better.
(not to you , but in general why is AND always highlighted?)
Lose the wavy computery looking green stuff in front of the water tower and let it stand alone.
Try all-caps on the tagline.

 

[signmeup]

Hire Colin. He does logos for $495. (Sorry for reviving on old post)