Replacing Fascia

The church I go to is wanting to redo their sign.

It's a brick sign, that goes up to a wooden roof (maybe 6 ft tall total?)

It's shingled, and it has some fascia board right under the rafters. This was painted white, and then black painted letters on it YEARSSS ago.

Well it has cracked, and split over the 20 years it has been there probably, and they are looking to replace it, and put vinyl letters on it.

What do you think would be the best substrate to put back up there, for the media to adhere to?

Obviously not wood, because it swelling would cause major issues..

Any ideas?

 

The main thing I'm worried about right now is the surface texture in accepting the vinyl lettering.

I wonder how well aluminum trim coil would accept vinyl lettering? I know over time it can get chalky..

 

Here is the thing that would need replacing, note the front where the "First Free Will Baptist Church"

 

That's a pretty cool idea.. thanks!

HP? New to this so what's the acronym

It's def a simple job, but I'm 17 getting into this. The church asked me to come up with some information on updating the sign, so I thought I'd take it on as a little project. Most of my stuff just deals with vinyl.

Haha, I like the Bingo idea.. too bad that'd fall through in a vote..