Here's a list of what I've used in the past...
Glass (my preference)- works great as a weeding tabletop only. Insures straight, clean cuts and smooth tape application every time. With care, it will last forever.
Acrylic/Polycarbonate (also my preference) - A cheap (you can get paid by charging a disposal fee to get one) , nearly indesctructable tabletop that can last for quite a long time. You can flip it over when one side gets too grooved and sand it smooth again, when needed. But, you can just do another lighted sign face replacement to get another. I have yet to wear one out and that's at least 5 years. I'm still waiting to land my first back lit face replacement
Wood/OSB/Particle board - Some of the franchises use this. It's high maintenance though. When it starts getting grooved (about once a month), just coat it out with some high quality, oil based paint.
Metal - Very durable, but can be tough on your tools/product.
Cutting mats - While they do exactly what they say, I feel the other methods are more cost effective.
PVC - Too soft. In a busy shop, I would replace the tops every other month.
HDPE - Not my first choice, but it works too. I have a HDPE cutting board that I use in my current shop. The thinner material is a little less stable than other choices of similar size. It can buckle when there's a sudden change of temperature.
Checkers