The hand held machine seems a lot better to me if I'm being honest. People have successfully hand routed objects for years. The human is able to control feed rates pretty damn well and because you can react to feedback, it keeps you out of trouble
I just can't imagine that hanging router being anything but a headache. I have a decent hobby/light industrial 4x8 machine with NEMA34 steppers and a 3.25HP router and even that will give me hell when machining even if it's just part hold down being the issue. I just can't imagine that router hanging by some chain and using bricks as counter weights being a reliable machine. If you want to play around and cut out cheap 1/4" plywood, maybe it's okay, but I can't imagine using it as anything but a toy.
I just can't imagine that hanging router being anything but a headache. I have a decent hobby/light industrial 4x8 machine with NEMA34 steppers and a 3.25HP router and even that will give me hell when machining even if it's just part hold down being the issue. I just can't imagine that router hanging by some chain and using bricks as counter weights being a reliable machine. If you want to play around and cut out cheap 1/4" plywood, maybe it's okay, but I can't imagine using it as anything but a toy.