Thanks for the replies. I'm off to get a metal cutting blade and give it a try.
For a better idea of what I'm cutting it's a 30"x35" sign with an arched top and a starfish poking off one side. I've got a ton of these to do, and was thinking about making a template out of thick max-metal and routing the edges. Tried routing and it makes more mess than it's worth.
Update. Just jigged two and they turned out fine, only a little clean up. Takes some time though, about 25 min on each.