Logo critique

[Jen Goodwin]

Can you guys give me opinions on this?
Any thoughts would be great! (even if you hate it. LOL)

 

[SignManiac]

I don't really consider that a logo and that's one odd looking cat. What is this intended for?

 

[jfiscus]

ditto, looks like an album cover, not a logo.

 

[HulkSmash]

that's not a cat...

 

[WI]

You might be on to something if you got rid of the dogs and just tucked "& Kitty" right under "Three Dogs." As it stands you're gonna flub the postage-stamp test pretty badly.

 

[SIGNTIME]

haha that "kitty"

 

[Edna]

3 dogs and a fox?

 

[Border]

3 Dogs and a biology experiment gone wrong?

 

[Jen Goodwin]

LOL...I digitized the dogs from photos of my customer's dogs...and "Kitty" is a dog. It's for a small doggie daycare...and I understand the 'this is not a logo' but that is what my customer wanted and what she's calling it, so I am not going to argue.
We are planning on using just the type like you stated WI.

 

[ForgeInc]

Ugh...another "this is what my customer wanted, so I am not going to argue" response.

Then why post it for critique?

 

[Jen Goodwin]

I don't know...I am starting to wonder. So no comments on anything except "It's not a logo so screw?" Whatever.
Thanks for suggestions on making more logo-like. I appreciate it.

 

[aandrews19]

What if it was just the heads, instead of the entire body. I think the actual dogs are actually taking away from the name, because they are the main focus. Try "three dogs" as the focus, with the dog heads over top, and "& kitty" below.

 

[TammieH]

Yeah, I agree its not really a logo...a logo is more than a picture/drawing/clip art and a title or a few initials. It looks OK, other than that, BTW Jen did not say it was a cat, it could be a dog named "Kitty"

The dogs are cute...enough said!

 

[ucmj22]

scrap, start over. you'll thank me later.

 

[visual800]

place all letering at bottom of logo and maybe 4 head shots of the animals up top, this sucks cause the customer asked for it, they dont know what they want

 

[Jillbeans]

It's all just kind of hanging there like pieces of furniture on different corners of a room.
Add an area rug (a background shape) to pull then all together.
Love....Jill

 

[WI]

Hang on to the dogs, you might be able to use them for t-shirts or something like that down the road. Remember, less is more. Glad I could help.

 

[bob]

scrap, start over. you'll thank me later.

Exactly so.

This looks like a third rate talent working at full capacity using MS Publisher. Try again. It doesn't matter what the client wants so much as what the client needs.

 

[ProWraps]

the dog on the left screams "PUT ME DOWN!!! I'M TIRED!"

 

[fmg]

What did you puff last night?