Your about to be next on my ignore list. I've designed many great signs, but sometimes I have no control over what the customer wants like Order Up! I sent her all the designs posted and some others and she turned them down and wants it more like the original. This church wants modern, basic and blue/white only, so it really limits me.
Thats up to you, but I really think you could learn something. Maybe it's the way you come off? Maybe I could react better?
So, there are 2 types of designers - most sign shops "Execute" design. When you become an expert - you start to become more "strategic" Strategic pays better...
When you "execute" design work, it's at the clients whim, you as an expert have to guide them through it. What you have been showing is not "expert" work. Once you show the client you are not the expert, you couldn't sell a heater to an Eskimo... I do believe we all have to start somewhere, but I was under the assumption you have been doing this for quite a while.
Like the order up logo, once you show something that the client can do, you are totally screwed, it's hard to get into the "expert" mode again. If I was designing this sign, my advice is (by the way, I practice what I preach)
-- Stay away from sign shop fonts,
-- Research other wayfinding signs
-- Give them options right off the bat so you can give them a choice, if you spent the 1 minute to pick another - not so decorative typeface - you would be printing this up by now.
If you need help learning to design - don't rely on what you know... google it!
By the way, not all is lost, your ORDER UP sign (not logo) was way better than any example shown on that thread. And the one thing I was frustrated about was not you... it was not one person asked "WHAT KIND OF FOOD DO THEY MAKE?"