Fred Weiss
Merchant Member
Hmmmm? I'll bet that the color-trapping problem grows slightly with each successive color/foil. Yes?
Actually, no. The error in color to color registration is directly related to the amount of foil that remains unused in the cartridge which affects the x-axis position of each color. In a print using three spot colors with the first and third color being new, unused foils and the second being half used, a shift of position of up to .020" on the second color can be anticipated with a near perfect return to the original color on the third color.
Also, friction feed comes in lots of flavors. Some supremely accurate; much more so than tractor-fed. Others, terribly inaccurate.
Factors affecting friction tracking accuracy are:
Design, first and foremost. The relationship between the drive drum (grit spindle), the media and the pinch roller is massively critical, especially but not limited to the grit pattern. Roller tension, too, is a big deal.
Next, the supremely matched outside circumference of the drive drum at the points of pinch roller contact. They must match, exactly. An oxidation-resistant coating, also a must. Oxidation alters the circumference.
Lastly, the smooth delivery of material. Any stress, to one side or the other, steers the web.
Get it all right, and nothing touches it for accuracy. Tractor feed's advantage is also its inherent flaw: to have the tollerances that fricion is capable of, the release of the vinyl from the pins would be too tight. Its other flaw is the vinyl manufacture. The cutter is only as good as the puncher that put the holes in the vinyl. No manufacturer gets it exactly right 100% of the time. (understatement)
Back at ya ... :^)
I cannot disagree that your comments are valid to a point. I would still assert that my original point of allowing in the graphic design for print to cut registration errors by use of edge bleeds or unprinted contours, as well as reducing the size of production runs of repeated items will save a lot of lost production or inferior output.