I would wrap with the 3M material as it comes of clean.
As I say wrapping anything, "it is only as good as the surface you are applying it to".
If the materials are flaky it will not work.
On a sub note even if these are a temporary wrap they should be priced the same as normal.
I had a customer of mine wanting me to temporary wrap a racing Bentley for the weekend!
Yes it's true he has about 5 or 6 Bentleys.
And this was all because of trying to get back and play a trick on some of his racing buddies!
He wanted the race car to look like his standard road car.
But being a guy with plenty money he could not get it in his head that this was still a wrap and for it to look authentic still cost the same as a standard colour change wrap!
Even if it was just going to be a bit of a joke for the weekend!!