We used the MacTac product. It looks great. Looks just like paint. Everyone that sees it swears it was painted on. Insignia hooked us up with it, give him a shout.
Thanks! (-:
I will say we've been using the 3M product for about 2 years now and the Mactac for about a year and I feel like the 3M holds up a little better having seen them both out in the real world for a while now.
They adhere differently, the MacTac just has an aggressive adhesive, the 3M actually hardens to the shape/texture of the surface it's being applied to and that helps hold it in place. It's looking like over time on some rougher textures (stucco and rough brick in particularly) the 3M is staying stuck longer because it's formed to the texture where the MacTac's adhesive is losing it's grip. Nothing extreme, but you can see the difference. We have a job that was done about 20 months ago on stucco, outdoors, that looks like new. We had to add some pieces to it about 7 month sago and we used MacTac to see how they'd hold up and the MacTac is letting go a bit now. Which is really to be expected, it's only rated for 6-12 months outside and stucco is a pretty extreme texture. Surprisingly the 3M is holding up much better than expected as it's only rated for
up to 6 months outdoors.
They're both good products, just make sure your customer knows they're not super-long-term products, especially outside.