In shops not equipped with exotic cutting tackle such as water jets, lasers, death rays, etc. and in descending order of desirability...
Cutawl: The definitive pattern cutting mechanism. You can pad the work to ~1" depending on the blade you're using.
Band saw: Next best but the speed of the blade tends to melt coroplast regardless of in-feed speed. You can pad the work up to 6" or more. The are limitations on the size of the work depending on the size of the band saw.
Jigsaw: Only if you have nothing else. It's possible to pad the work to maybe 1.5".
Knives, scissors, pointed sticks, etc. should only be used if you were to be washed up on some deserted island and that's all there was.