i've been reading this thread, but initally didn't respond because i don't have daughters. last night as i was reading, i thought... i may not have daughters, but i WAS a daughter, who at age 15, refused to speak to my parents, for 8 months, unless absolutely necessary.
but didn't write again because the situation/circumstances were so dissimilar, i didn't see how it would help to explain that... so again didn't comment.
and tonight... still feeling so sad for you Gary... and at such a loss for words of advice... i'm not sure if this bit of info will be helpful... but it was something i insisted on in our home... and it applied equally, without exception to EVERYONE, my husband, myself and my boys. it may seem insignificant to some, and maybe you won't see the importance in it... but to me... i can't think of one single thing that was more important to me... maybe even more so now, than when my boys were young.
sorry for the long lead in, but i know it's bigger than it it'll sound.
from the time my boys went to kindergarten and realized, in the world outside their home, people, both adults and kids could say anything and treat you anyway they wanted to. they could be mean, hurtful, rude, spew ugliness or be bullies and chances are... it would be allowed.
the absolute LAW was this...
when you walk through the door of THIS house, you'll never be called a name, never be belittled, never be made fun of and NEVER be verbally or physically abused... and YOU will never treat ANYONE else in THIS house THAT way.
i told the boys this was a their "Safe Haven." no matter what happened outside, in here... directing ugliness, cruelty or unreasonable levels of anger towards anyone else in the house, was simply NOT ALLOWED. as silly as it might sound to tell a little kid... they were told "as long as you live here, THAT'S THE LAW."
so how does this relate to your situation... it only really does in one area... but i think it's a biggy... and that's in the way your daughter has treated YOU and the horrible, hurtful things she said to your wife.
i can tell from what you've written, that you're daughter isn't treated and spoken to the way she's speaking to you. she needs to know, if your wife had spoken to her that way... she'd be OUT and only allow IN when she didn't threaten to destroy the "safe haven."
that doesn't mean, it's all sunshine & daises and hugs & kisses. it just means NOT directing undeserved or unreasonable angry at others. have a pity party or a tantrum in your room if you need to, but you don't get to subject others to it.
it's not THE answer to every problem that arises, but rational communication is a helluva ground rule... and a helluva good start.
this of course is barring any mental illness AND parents who don't think the same applies to them.
p.s. my kids we're yelled at and spanked on a few occasion when it was warranted. just because you're not allowed to talk sh!t, doesn't mean you get away with sh!t.
sorry i could give anything that more specifically address the problem you're having with your daughter Gary... but maybe your daughter knowing your house is "her safe haven" ...maybe someday she'll realize how much energy it takes to be unfair, unkind and angry... that it sucks the happiness out of everyone they subject to it.
no one person should be allowed to suck the happiness out of a household... no matter how old they are!
ugh... seriously... sorry to have rambled on so.