Welcome To Signs101.com: Largest Forum for Signmaking Professionals

Signs101.com: Largest Forum for Signmaking Professionals is the LARGEST online community & discussion forum for professional sign-makers and graphic designers.

 


  1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

** The Official Illustrator vs. Corel Draw Thread **

Discussion in 'General Software' started by synergy_jim, Dec 20, 2007.

Which it better, Illustrator or Corel Draw?

Poll closed Jan 19, 2008.
  1. Illustrator

    36 vote(s)
    42.4%
  2. Corel Draw

    27 vote(s)
    31.8%
  3. I use them both

    22 vote(s)
    25.9%
  4. I still do everything by hand....

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  1. synergy_jim

    synergy_jim Very Active Member

    I have been using adobe illustrator, and the rest of the adobe gamut for years.

    I must say that the versatility and cooperation between adobe's different programs is amazing, especially with the CS3 apps.

    Nothing against corel, but to me it seems like a kids toy next to illustrator.
    I admit that using corel after illustrator feels like driving on the wrong side of the road backwards.

    I just want to pick everyones brains as far as corel tutorial sites and things that you think corel does better so I can make a more informed decision.

    Thanks,

    JD
     
    Tags:
  2. tyans1

    tyans1 Member

    74
    0
    0
    Jul 8, 2006
    I prefer Corel.... but it's just because I am faster in it. I was a beta tester for both.
     
  3. javila

    javila Active Member

    843
    0
    0
    Jul 30, 2006
    I use adobe to modify/design things. I can't stand the interface on corel draw. Too menu driver it seems to me.

    I love corel for ouputting sperations and working multi page files though. I'd love to have an illustrator interface with corels outputting options.
     
  4. iSign

    iSign Major Contributor

    13,027
    31
    48
    Nov 29, 2003
    Kahului, Maui
    informed decision on what... if you already have & know how to use illustrator... even the most vocal of the Corel supporters in the many years of previous "official" corel-illustrator duel threads... would ususally never claim Corel to be worthy enough to abandon Illustrator if it's already working for you...

    ...with one exception. Using Corel to output to a (Roland) plotter without buying an expensive bridge or other cutting program.
     
  5. johnnysigns

    johnnysigns Very Active Member

    1,195
    4
    38
    Nov 3, 2004
    East Coast
    i despise corel.
     
  6. MobileImpact

    MobileImpact Active Member

    759
    0
    0
    Oct 11, 2005
    Whats Corel?

    Just kidding, We use Illy, Have Corel but hate it.
     
  7. synergy_jim

    synergy_jim Very Active Member

    well...

    the informed decision is " Am I missing anything "

    Thats all... I own both, but have never really learned corel....

    should I invest the time, or am I really not missing much?
     
  8. Checkers

    Checkers Very Active Member

    2,698
    3
    0
    Jul 24, 2003
    Both programs have their place, but I prefer Corel's suite because
    1) it's all inclusive (vector, raster, animation, trace, publishing and web design) for the cost of illustrator alone
    2) Page size is unlimited
    3) you can do multiple pages in one file (newsletters and books)
    4) it works well with microsoft office suite
    5) its a lot more sign maker friendly.

    Checkers
     
  9. Rick

    Rick Certified Enneadecagon Designer

    6,955
    389
    83
    Apr 17, 2003
    Valle Vista
    I don't think it matters...if the user can't design, or does not know how to get a file ready for any kind of production situation, then who cares what they use.
     
  10. Shovelhead

    Shovelhead Major Contributor

    10,882
    16
    0
    Dec 5, 2003
    I think the question is very vague.....for illustrating...Illustrator hands down.
    For everyday sign drawings...Corel
    I literally only use Illustrator to manipulate native files and live trace every so often.
     
  11. bob

    bob Major Contributor

    5,275
    306
    83
    Nov 4, 2005
    earth
    They're what's known as fungible products. They're functionally pretty much the same. The contention is the same as you would observe with a posse of rednecks arguing whether their Ford, GM, or Dodge truck is the superior specimen.

    Of course you'll never convince a buck Adobe or Corel chauvinist to admit to it.

    Use which ever gets you off. I prefer Corel but I have no doubt that what ever I can do in one of them I can do in the other. My preference for Corel is based on nothing more than that's what I've used for lo these many years.
     
  12. GK

    GK Very Active Member

    2,004
    2
    38
    Apr 30, 2007
    NYC
    You could do that in Illustrator too, I posted a link a while back about how to do just that after I saw so many people (not just this forum) thinking the same thing.
     
  13. Flame

    Flame Major Contributor

    8,283
    7
    38
    Apr 26, 2006
    Vancouver
    It's like what someone else said.... "my pencil is better than your pencil". It's whatever you're comfortable with. I started in Illustrator, I ended up in CorelDraw. Some drawing functions are easier in Illustrator, but for everyday vector and some raster work... it's hard to beat Corel for me.

    You can do well in both, but why I like Corel over Illustrator:

    1. Unlimited page dimensions

    2. Bevel tool

    3. Contour tool (rather than using outlines and converting to curves, filling... etc.)

    4. Better text manipulation

    5. More presets for gradients, fills, patterns and vector shapes

    6. Easier to zoom in and out (middle rolle button)

    7. Having a easy to use Calendar wizard right at hand

    8. Easier to work with Rasters. Even in program editing tools such as image adjustment, color adjustment, special effects etc.



    Just some reasons I'm an X3 lover.
     
  14. copperheadsigns

    copperheadsigns Member

    183
    0
    16
    May 19, 2006
    this will largely split along Mac and PC lines, I would guess...

    if you are a Mac user, you'll likely prefer Illustrator...if you are a PC user, you might like Corel more.

    ??? any takers on this theory?

    I have both and much prefer Illustrator.
     
  15. Craig Sjoquist

    Craig Sjoquist Major Contributor

    6,746
    4
    38
    Jun 18, 2004
    Orlando
    I own corel X3 love it will buy more corel products to complete like painter before adobe

    anyway went to school for adobe to try to learn ....reliezed that it's also needed software ...some stuff was easier some not but still very useful

    so voted both

    but 90% of my work is done by hand
    not a good poll to me it does not really get a survey correctly

    Merry Christmas
     
  16. GrumpyMonkeyDesigns

    GrumpyMonkeyDesigns Member

    49
    0
    0
    Oct 22, 2007
    I am a pc user and prefer Corel for mostly the same reasons that Flamey listed.(especially the contour tool, the middle button zoom and the transparency tool). I use photoshop,imageready and adobe Golive, as well and dont find them difficult to use, but couldnt really get a feel for illustrator. But I also never really committed myself to learn illustrator as corel saves as a psd. file if photoshop.

    Warren
     
  17. Techman

    Techman Major Contributor

    8,520
    8
    38
    Jun 24, 2003
    michigan
    Now that every one has sung the praises of Illy,, I'll inject a few tidbits of detritus to remind us all that the adobe god illy does have flaws just like any other software..

    Illustrator has too many bugs for the price you have to pay for it..

    Try catching a node. The resolution is so fine that its a hit or miss gamble. At least they could have made a slider to adjust the resolution..
    Try following a tutorial. If you can find one that is complete.

    Corel comes with full functions.
    Illy requires that you purchase expensive other plug ins to make it work.

    MAx page size is 227.. x 227 INCHES. (I don't remember if this is the exact size)

    Free transform bugs are the biggest pain,, Especially on gradient mesh and envelopes
    illustrator crashes, and there is no autosave / rescue file that corel does have.Crash protection is an industry standard with nearly every other drawing soft..

    Select a path to see the points. Try to select and delete a node point and Illy cannot find it unless you are exactly there,, or it highlights some other path.

    Click on the triangle to drop a layer group. miss the mark and try again Illy crashes along with the last 28 minutes of drawing. (no autosave or crash recovery)

    There's also an issue with deleting colors in the Live Color dialog.

    Oh yes,, don't forget the memory fragmented.. Memory leakage with cs3,, illy fragments memory forcing you to own a memory defrag to keep working. Get involved into a project that takes a few hours and your gonna have a memory problem.

    Bridge hangs up sometimes. too much..

    The load speed gains that is nice in XP is gone in Vista fistula.

    And finally the vector layers loss. You cannot paste a vector into the proper layer every time. It misses sometimes.

    Anything with a rounded corner will instantly become a needle point sharp corner in free transform..

    I will admit that adobe may have fixed these by now,, I don't really care. I use corel and do not have a hassle with it at all... But i do know the node grabber is still way to finicky in illy...

    tech...
     
  18. Columbia Signs

    Columbia Signs Member

    300
    0
    0
    Aug 7, 2007
    I use both. 95% Corel and 5% AI.
     
  19. The Vector Doctor

    The Vector Doctor Very Active Member

    3,496
    144
    63
    Aug 15, 2005
    Ohio
    You would be hard pressed to find a Mac person that prefers Corel, especially since the last version of Corel was around the time of OS9.

    For Mac people the real debate is Illustrator/Freehand and Indesign/Quark
     
  20. Flame

    Flame Major Contributor

    8,283
    7
    38
    Apr 26, 2006
    Vancouver
    But now Freehand is going BYE BYE!!!
     
Loading...

Share This Page

 


Loading...