You know my last post about the state of our industry got me thinking. There is an obvious divide between veteran professionals and new sign makers. This post is to hopefully try to understand this divide. So, without further ado…
Joe’s test for newbies:
(The goal here is to get above 0. If you can get above 0, in my opinion, you are worth the help from others.)
A. The newbie properly introduces his or her self in this post or another post
( +1 point)
A proper introduction is always helpful. It allows the people that you are asking for help to determine whether or not you are going to take their help seriously when they give it. It’s also good manors.
B. Not only has the newbie posted an introduction, but he or she has participated in a constructive way on other posts.
( +2 points )
This goes along way. It shows others that you are serious about this profession and more importantly you are attempting to be helpful or contribute.
C. The newbie demands answers, without supplying background information.
( -1 point )
How are people going to determine if their help is going to be taking seriously? Is the newbie only looking for quick answers and shortcuts with out contributing? Why should I help you if you’re not helpful yourself? Outside of the internet, do you usually walk up to a group of strangers and demand answers for your questions?
D. Newbie asks a frequently asked question.
( -2 points )
It’s called searching. Now the newbie is just being lazy. This proves to me that the person isn’t willing to work for their answers, so why should I work to try to answer them.
E. Newbie uses the phrases “it’s a hobby”, “what’s the cheapest way to get started”, “can you give me ___ for free” ...and so on.
( -3 points )
If you’re not going to take our industry seriously, why should we take you seriously?
F. Newbie asks can you design this for me.
( -1000000 )
You failed the test. Don’t even bother trying to finish this little math exercise….
That is unless you plan on paying me
( +2000000 ):ROFLMAO:
Okay on to the next problem:
The Newbie’s question has been asked. If you got higher then 0, then in most cases you will get your help, and it will be positive. If you got lower then 0, then chances are most of your responses will be negative. You may still get some help but since you didn’t have respect when asking the question, it is now your responsibility to search through the negative comments for actual help.
So how does the newbie respond to the answers and comments?:
A. They take the advice given and say thank you.
( +5 )
Not only did they learn something and acknowledge that the comments made were helpful, but they were polite also. If the newbie scored below 0 in the first question, at least they have the ability to make up for it here and hopefully gain some respect.
B. The Newbie argues with the answers supplied.
( -5 )
By arguing with the answers, to me, you are saying that you already know it all. Then why are you asking the question? Are you just fishing for the answers you want to hear? What is your motive? Now I’m confused and I’m unsure how I’m supposed to further help you. Besides you obviously have all the answers anyway.
C. Not only does the newbie argue, but he or she also insults one of the members who are trying to help.
( -10 )
Now you’re just being a jerk. No one wants to help a person if instead of being thanked they are attacked. In my opinion, after this happens, you’re on your own.
So if you’re a Newbie what score did you get? It’s really easy to get above a 0 if a little common sense is used.
Whether or not the greater majority of newbies score below 0 on my little math problem, or if the majority of them score higher, most of the professionals remember the newbies that score low. This may explain their attitude toward new people. But since when has a rookie in any profession deserved automatic respect. Just like every thing in life, you have to work for it.
The point I’m trying to make is: I’m not an expert on every thing. I have questions too. But when I ask them, I subconsciously go through this little equation first to see if my question is worth the help. The problem I see with newbies asking questions has less to do with whether or not I’m willing to help and more to do with the way they ask the question. I would expect the same if I was asking a question.
A lot of newbies don’t think they have to prove anything to veteran sign makers. Why not? When I started out it was my goal to prove to these guys that I was worth their time. I’m still trying to prove myself. Hopefully these people notice that and realize that I’m worth a little bit of their extra time and wisdom. That is how I learn.
Now that I’ve been at it a while, and I feel I can contribute by answering questions, I am constantly making the judgment call on whether or not I should help someone new. The last thing I want to do is help those with the wrong attitude and a lack of understanding, saturate this industry with bad sign shops.