It looks like you had a party in your pants with a bunch of oddball fonts and you all ended up doing the Macarena.
The second one looks pretty much the same except you decided to do the YMCA.
Not one of those fonts is serious, and outlining them and inappropriately shadowing them just looks sillier.
Please, for the love of God and all things sacred to us sign folks, do read the Mike Stevens book I told you about yesterday. And check out Dan Antonelli's logo design books. Or if you get real lucky on eBay, some of Cecil Ward's books or even the rare H.C.Martin books.
I am not going to go into the technical critique of the card as it has all been said already. You seem like a nice guy and eager to make signs. Get just as eager to learn how to make them the correct way, using good contast, a nice snappy layout, etc. What you design should look great in black and white even before you start adding effects and things.
Pat, it is an honor to be compared to John Deaton. I think we both like the same colors and alphabets, we are both big fans of Arthur Vanson, who is my biggest mentor.
I am still learning how to design after 24 years of signs and about 4 years on Corel now.
Love....Jill
PS
Pay special attention to Slapakiss (Steph) she started out knowing literally nothing about signs and look how far she has come in such a short time. By listening to good advice and practicing. Flame did this too.