Lil’
I think you have been exceptionally patient and receptive to the truck load of constructive criticism you have received. Although a few critiques were offered with little to no input how to positively move forward, many others passed along great insight in regards to how to attain solid layout skills. Many business card layout proposals or possibilities were also submitted. Even though most were very good to excellent, I think you were right to turn them down on the basis that the Look or Personality of those layouts was not “Yours”. Your business needs to reflect you, not someone else.
In response to those submissions, you introduced an example (post 75) that displayed the Personality or Feel you would like your business card to have; your “Ideal” look. While some may not like the “look”, it is the direction you have stated as being your preference. Shortly there after, you submitted another attempt (post 101). That submission fell short of your ideal look. The “Ideal” layout is well proportioned and has reasonable contrast. Take a look at your “Ideal” layout from graphicdisorder.com again. It has a dark background with 1 graphic in the center. The layout works because the dark background and the foreground of the graphic work together to provide contrast to the text of the graphic itself. The text POPS, particularly “Custom”. What I mean by POPS is that at a very quick glance you are able to quickly read the text. If you were to use that very layout and you substituted your signature version of “lil Details” for “Twin States Customs”, it would not work, even though the rest of the cards layout has already been established as the “Look” or feel that you would like to replicate. It would not work because the weight or stroke of the “lil Details” is very weak and provides very little contrast. Also, the Graphic “Style” is not the same as what already exists. However, if that same signature had been generated with a broad tipped marker or some similar method, then maybe the layout may have had a higher probability of success. CONTRAST is KING.
If you are determined that the thin stroked signature is the way to go, then Biker Scout (post 113) did a great job of presenting a thin stroked logo with power. He also used a complimentary font so that the secondary copy did not over power the signature logo. Although his effort did not completely match the characteristics you were looking for, it was very solid.
You don’t need to change your identity (lil Details) as some have suggested, rather all that is needed is to change HOW it is being presented. Make up your mind what personality you want your business image to have and then figure out how to best accomplish it. Don’t get caught up in having a certain background, but rather focus on the overall impact. Does the content of the layout work together to present the image that you want…legibly? If you are not sure, print out the layouts and tape them to a wall 5 to 10 feet away and quickly look at them. If you have to study them to read them, you have failed and will need to start over. If indeed you are not in a big hurry, then I would recommend that you take your time and try out as many ideas as you can. Post those efforts that you feel stoked about. Constructive and positive critiques will certainly come.
Pat Whatley just provided yet another great example proving that it can be done.
Many great resources have been cited in this thread. Check them out if at all possible. Learning how to use fonts appropriately will go a long way towards improving your layout skills. A list of fonts to NOT use was provided. That list was probably created because the author felt those fonts were over used. You CAN use them and create fine layouts, but just be aware that EVERYBODY , especially newbies and/or Word document users, etc. use the hell out of them. Be original, but do it with legibility in mind. Stick with it and don’t get discouraged. Seek out the best and learn what they do and why they do it.
Sorry for the long response. I just wanted to encourage you to hang in there.
Good luck and best wishes.