Sergio,
I agree with you on some parts. Most, Sign Makers, or "Wrap designers" in today's industry are self taught. And have no idea how to utilize both programs. Most stick to one- Photoshop. They love the effects and what not. In my opinion most are cheesy. One of the most revered wrap designers in my opinion is Dan A. His stuff is top notch, and not once has his stuff entered into Photoshop.
Can you HONESTLY say these 2 wraps are quality photoshop designs?
You can look through here -
http://www.graphicd-signs.com/portfolio-vehicle-advertising#1 to see what i mean by illustrator having more of an impact with professionalism.
as i said before photoshop is a great program to work in harmony with illustrator. the eps templates are dead on....and we rarely have to adjust.
I love this! Lets make sure we are all on the same page and discussing the same thing to make the terms equal.
Artwork- Can be created either via raster or vector formats. Agreed?
Design- This is objectionably judged based on ones experience, knowledge and
skill set. To the laymen both of those may or may not be good design however amongst professionals the bar is higher. Agreed?
Skill- An artist with skill can design in microsoft paint and do a better job than someone without skill working in photoshop, illustrator, corel, flexi etc. Agreed?
That being said- The examples you showed me were great/ awesome/ outstanding designs that are vector based but... created at the hand of a very skilled artist whom I would be willing to bet, if he wanted to could kick arse in photoshop as well.
This example is arguably a good raster design.
http://www.coroflot.com/bradzilla/portfolio - Another great example of an Artist who designs primarily in photoshop.
This one took best of show in one of the sign mags-
http://www.thewrapshoppe.com/car-wraps-photos/the_wrap_shoppe/car_wraps/_DSC0529_for web (1).jpg#
all photoshop based.
And last but not least- This is a girl in Tucson who makes most of us look like crayon artists in illustrator.
http://lifeinvector.com/vectors/
Good design is good design. Photoshop VS illustrator is like saying Tyson VS Tito Ortiz or maybe like saying Micheal Angelo VS Micheal Jackson.
It all boils down to what is going to make you the most productive artist, make your clients phone ring and provide an honest living for you and your employees.
At the end of the day I have personally seen clients demand garbage designs and pay a ton for it and leave happier than a pig in (*&!.
You will never hear me bash Mr. Clip art or PVO or anyone else for that matter, if you work in photoshop and want a great template ill help you out. If not no worries I will still help if I can. I personally suggest you have as many tools as possible.
Once again, I truly respect your opinion and your thoughts on the matter are most certainly relevant!
That was a mouthful... Back to work.
Respectfully,
Sergio